Solidarity Not Charity
Collaborative Solidarity with Indigenous Communities
NVR deeply values co-creation and collaboration as vital for moving resources to Indian Country, because when we let go of competition, scarcity, and charity, we recognize that we are stronger together. Only through trusting, cooperative kinship with the Indigenous Peoples of these lands can bold visions of abundant futures for all come alive on Turtle Island and beyond.
What is collaborative grantmaking?
Collaborative grantmaking happens when a collective of funders and donors pool their resources together for redistribution to grassroots and frontline organizations and movements leading systemic social change.
Collaborative funds are efficient and effective because they uplift the unique expertise of each partner and combine a wealth of networks to generate results that cannot be achieved alone. (Read: The Collaborative Effect (opens in a new tab) by Philanthropy Together.)
Relationships are at the heart of NVR’s collaborative grantmaking approach.
For over 13 years, we have been committed to and successfully engaging in 100% Native community-led participatory grantmaking. Now, NVR is well known as a uniting force among Native-led organizations and non-Native philanthropic partners alike.
We fundraise on behalf of Native-led organizations, accessing more abundant pools of wealth than would otherwise flow to Native communities. And we welcome our non-Native philanthropic funding partners into a circle of giving that reciprocates their generosity with valuable wisdom and new connections to Native leadership on the ground – ones they typically can’t make on their own.
In fact, NVR was launched as a direct response to report findings that funders (1) did not understand Native communities, (2) could not properly evaluate strong Native organizations, and (3) were uncertain how to build trust with Native communities.
As a result, we teach and demonstrate in practice eight specific recommendations first published in our 2021 report A Case for Funding Native-led Change. Our recommendations challenge traditional “charity” models that continue to harm Indigenous communities around the world and demonstrate more just and equitable solutions rooted in Indigenous values.
By design, NVR collects every dollar of our budget by asking our supporters for grants and donations. We then redistribute 70% of it. Our model is distinctly different from private foundations that are only required to give 5% of their assets each year and that raise their budgets from invested endowments. With the remaining funds raised, we spend 15% on supportive assistance given to grantee partners, and 15% on operations.
NVR’s model requires our funding partners to show up differently: to share accumulated power, to honor community expertise, and to choose relationships over transactions. Together, we are teaching philanthropy how to use its power and privilege in true solidarity with Indigenous Peoples. That starts with trusting Native sovereignty and self-determination.
Key elements of our approach include:
- Native leadership: NVR takes the design lead in ongoing co-creative sessions.
- Participatory decision making: Grant decisions are made by Native leaders and practitioners from the applicant communities.
- Long-term commitment: Four years of general operating funding for grantee partners to spend less time on fundraising.
- Cohort-based capacity building: grantee partners participate in quarterly peer learning gatherings and are matched with one-on-one coaching by Native professionals.
- Accountability: Grantee partners shape the experience through ongoing feedback loops.
Get Involved
Native Voices Rising welcomes conversations with anyone interested in exploring collaborative grantmaking partnerships. Whether through multi-year funding initiatives, capacity-building support, or participation in our Good Relatives Program for funders, there are multiple pathways into this circle.
For those ready to link up, we recommend learning more about our prolific partnership with Magic Cabinet, which offers a proof point that this approach is tried and true.
